⭐⭐⭐⭐
In the Acknowledgments, author Annie Hartnett writes, "We're not safe. No one is safe anywhere. It is foolish to let your guard down.
So I decided I would take all those fears and anxieties and put them into a novel. I decided to take all my worries about not being a good enough parent or a generally capable enough person and put those worries in a book. And I decided I would make that novel as funny as I possibly could." (p. 366)
and after I read that, this book made a lot more sense. It's a very good read; it moves very quickly and it helped kick me out of the reading slump I had been in. But when I pause to think about the content of the book--so much death in many formats, families dealing with the death of a child, child sexual assault, cancer, trauma, the Vietnam War--it feels incredibly heavy. Hartnett, though, has written in a way that just feels incredibly light. I never got brought down by the content or what was going on. I don't know that I necessarily thought of it as a funny book, but it definitely didn't feel as dark as the subject matter.If you breeze over the details, the story itself is somewhat charming: PJ, now in his 60s, finds out that the girl he fell for in high school is newly widowed. So he decides to drive from Massachusetts to Arizona to declare his feelings--and winds up journeying with his daughter and the grandchildren of his estranged brother after their parents die. A cat named Pancakes also comes along. Hijinks (?) ensue. (The stop at Big Kevin's alpaca farm is excellent.)
The details, of course, matter. PJ is an alcoholic, charming to the people in town and his fellow barflies, but infuriating to his family...though his ex-wife and her partner allow him to use their house as essentially a second home and kind of baby him. The two kids are dealing with the immediate aftereffects of their parents' deaths. Daughter Sophie is at her wits' end with her father but is also trying to figure out her own life, and dealing with her childhood trauma. The characters are all incredibly well-done, frustrating and believable. I found myself veering between cheering PJ on and not being able to handle him at all. Same with all the other characters, really.
In the end, there were a few elements that I wasn't sure how I felt about; Hartnett perhaps got slightly too cute with a few resolutions, and PJ's ex's partner is a saint to the point that I don't know I can buy him. Plus the plot of Luna looking for her birth father...her feelings about the quest made sense, and honestly it played out realistically, but something about it was odd.
Though honestly, that's true of a LOT of the action and story beats! Still, though, recommend.








